What was or is top gun: Street Fighter or Mortal Kombat series?

I am still shocked that people can choose MK on this. Obviously, if you were just asking people's personal preference, then it would be another matter entirely.

Any hardcore fighting fan knows that the gameplay in SF series is miles ahead of MK and it's not even close. And that's completely disregarding sales/influence, which are undoubtedly on the SF side.
 
I am still shocked that people can choose MK on this. Obviously, if you were just asking people's personal preference, then it would be another matter entirely.

Any hardcore fighting fan knows that the gameplay in SF series is miles ahead of MK and it's not even close. And that's completely disregarding sales/influence, which are undoubtedly on the SF side.



Those two games can't be compared amigo and in their own right they are both awesome games.
I used to be able to finish both games and know both games well, even though I prefered SFII CE and played it way more i can completely relate how people can give MK and it's gameplay (which has less depth then SFII) more love.

Street Fighter isn't that good anyway, King of Fighters series tops any fighting game.
 
My Collection

SF2:WW
SF2:CE
SF2:HFx2
SSF2T
SFA3
Vampire Savior
MvC
MvC2
Power Stone
Project Justice (jpn)
SF3:3rd Strike

Tekken Tag
Tekken 4
Soul Calibur

Virtua Fighter
VF Remix
Dead or Alive 2

Sam Sho 2,3,4
Garou: MOTW
Last Blade 1,2
KOF 99, 2002
Fatal Fury, Art of Fighting

the only copies of MK I have are on the console...
NUFF SAID
 
Fighters I like in order.

SF:WW
SF:HF
SF:CE

Tekken TAG
Tekken 3
Tekken 2
Tekken 1

MK1
UMK3
MK2

Didn't really care for SSF2:
The announcer sounded like big bird, and all the new voice overs were horrible. The game was too damn colorful, that should have been called "Rainbow Edition". Super moves seemed generic. The if they would of just added the four new characters to HF I would have liked it more. Great idea, but didn't like the execution. Or maybe I'm just too old school.

King of fighters? really? LOL who remembers the lawsuit of CAPCOM v.s. Data East?
Fighter's History.... lame
 
I loved Street Fighter BITD, but I still own an MK3 cabinet (with MK, MK2 and MK4 PCBs) and a Killer Instinct 2 cab (with KI PCB). Had a SF2 and sold it. Street Fighter is really good, but MK is better for me.

BTW...I would argue SF had multiple misses. SF3 comes immediately to mind and this was discussed a few days ago.

Tekken and Virtua Fighter were way down the list IMO. Those 3D fighters with floating characters and regular punches that take off 20% of the opponents life meter weren't for me.
 
King of fighters? really? LOL who remembers the lawsuit of CAPCOM v.s. Data East?
Fighter's History.... lame

Data East?? SNK maybe?
And then later Capcom thinks it's such a fab series that they ask SNK to make a fighting game with them, Capcom vs SNK ,SVC chaos.


Omg few on this board know their fighting games,
King of Fighters is THE game, the combination from Fatal fury, Art of fighting and the new characters comming together, being able to fight with a team, The super specials, which were first shown in Fatal fury Special.
Awesome characters like Kyo Kusanagi, Rugal Bernstein (the most brutal combo killer and high power end boss ever)

hahahaa SF had non of that during that time, cmon get real



Oh here's the ultimate badass end boss, he has moves like the Kaiser Wave and the Genocide cutter.

 
Last edited:
^^ You can't say King of Fighters is better. That's like saying a 2011 corvette is better than a 57 corvette, becuase the 57 corvette didn't have seat belts and an mp3 player.

King of Fighters came after, and the only reason it existed was because Street Fighter II invented the genre.
 
^^ You can't say King of Fighters is better. That's like saying a 2011 corvette is better than a 57 corvette, becuase the 57 corvette didn't have seat belts and an mp3 player.

King of Fighters came after, and the only reason it existed was because Street Fighter II invented the genre.


Well said!!! and I agree with what you say.
only thing that keeps comming to mi mind is that in 95 SF was still ridding on the old invention, same stuff, yeah they had Fei Long, cammy etc on the Super street fighter but the game sucked balls compared to KOF which was a few levels above that.


Now you saying that's KOF never could have been without SF is completely true and that is the reason MK was so awesome in it's own unique right.
 
This topic wouldn't be complete without someone deliriously ranting about SNK as if no one knows what's up.
 
Data East?? SNK maybe?
And then later Capcom thinks it's such a fab series that they ask SNK to make a fighting game with them, Capcom vs SNK ,SVC chaos.

No it was Data East. I remember that time like it was last week. When FH came out, we were all like WTF?!?!?! This is sooooo a SF rip off. Capcom ended up loosing that lawsuit. lame.
http://www.patentarcade.com/2005/08/case-capcom-v-data-east-nd-cal-1994-c.html

@lyonsarcade Great point made about KoF and SF2 total truth right there.

@pookdoile Actually I remember seeing the first 2 MK movies and liking them. I thought they were well done. Now the one's after that.... well..... Many people liked the MK movies, and hated the SF movies. LOL
Street Fighter movies were a complete fail. It was also rumored that Van Dame fired his agent after the movie flopped because it was him the prevented Van dame going to Midway for doing screen scans for the game, and lost a chance to be in the MK movie. It all came down a little too late when the MK movies did good, and the SF movies didn't.
 
I love both series and they were a big part of the arcade for me. Just looking at the two games as fighters and how they compare, I'd have to give the edge to the Street Fighter games. To me the game play of the SF2 series is better than the MK games. I'm sure it's been said here already, but if you take away the blood from MK1, I don't think it could have done anywhere near as well. Like I said I love both of them, but from a pure fighting game standpoint, I think you gotta give the nod to the Street Fighter games.
 
I was hooked on the fatalities of the MK games and the character design. I played a lot of both growing up arcade and on the home consoles, but had the best time with MK (even with the SNES version - no blood). Even recently I went back through and played MK with my brother and I had forgotten how much of an angry bastard Goro can be if his meat claws get a hold of you, lol. Both great games though. Never got into the KoF games, is there one that stands out that everyone should play?

And I'll just throw which characters I liked to use for shits and giggles: MK usually played as Raiden and SF as E Honda.

Least favorite would be Sonya and Dhalsim.
 
King of fighters? really? LOL who remembers the lawsuit of CAPCOM v.s. Data East?
Fighter's History.... lame

Wow. You do realize Fighter's History/Data East has NOTHING to do with King of Fighters/SNK, right?

You also realize that Fatal Fury & Art of Fighting (which would eventually merge to become King of Fighters) was the brainchild of the original developers for Street Fighter, who left Capcom shortly after its creation, right?

Probably not, judging by this statement.

Honestly, the KOF and SF series are very different from each other in terms of tone. While SF was always about playing defensively and waiting for your opponent to open themselves up (just look at the Shoryuken - the move with the most priority, and it was meant to be used as an anti-air), KOF was about creating openings and playing offensively (Tech Rolls, Low Jumps and Runs were always meant for overpowering your opponent with rush-downs, mix-ups and ambiguous cross-ups.)

Whether you consider one play-style superior to another is just a matter of taste. Both are the top-dogs in their field, however.

Personally, I prefer KOF because of the team mechanic - you can have one member cover for another member's weaknesses. It gives you a lot of options. It's the same reason I consider Vampire Savior to be one of the most balanced games of all time - even when one character is clearly superior to another, every character has so many options at their disposal that an 8v2 match-up in the opponents favor can still go to you. Hell, I've seen VS tournaments won by Victor and Anakaris, who are considered the lowest tier in that game. With fighting games, it's all about options and mobility - and in SF, almost every character moves slow, and tends to have the same options (Fireball + Uppercut + Forward-movement skill like Hurricane Kicks, Psycho Drive, etc.)

Lack of options is actually another problem I have with MK. Every characters' Back+LK, Back + HK, and Down + HP is the same. Heck, almost every normal attack in the game is exactly the same. Special moves are the only thing that makes a character unique, yet mostly they are easily punished - a whiffed or blocked Shadow Kick, for instance, will leave you standing there for almost a second, just waiting to get punished. This just means that people are going to pick one of the maybe three characters with specials that can't be easily punished. (I remember Cyrax in MK3 being EXTREMELY popular.)
 
Last edited:
Wow. You do realize Fighter's History/Data East has NOTHING to do with King of Fighters/SNK, right?

You also realize that Fatal Fury & Art of Fighting (which would eventually merge to become King of Fighters) was the brainchild of the original developers for Street Fighter, who left Capcom shortly after its creation, right?

Probably not, judging by this statement.

Judging by your statement I do realize that you didn't read what I wrote very well. I never said it had anything to do with each other. Obviously Since Data East made FH & SNK made FF etc. They would have nothing to do with each other.

I was making a statement that someone actually liked FF over SF. Everyone has opinions.
I didn't know that the creators of SF left and made FF, that was a nice bit of trivia.

I'm not knocking FF or any of the NEO GEO games in any way. Because I did play them back in the day because it reminded me of street fighter, and grew up a fighters genre fan. But I fell off those titles real quick.

BTW I mentioned the lawsuit for nostalgic reasons.
 
Back
Top Bottom