Just chiming in to say I am currently in the process of completing an order of tokens for our collecting group like TheShanMan said.
I designed our tokens and worked with the mint. I can answer any questions.
I will say that most coin mints offer ZCP (Zinc Copper Plated) tokens. They are cheaper, but don't order them. They are too light and will get stuck in most coin mechs. Go with brass.
Just curious what the cost of the tokens you chose to make were? Basically total # of tokens and total cost?
is the cost similar to what HHaase mentions below?
"I'm about to do a run of tokens myself actually, two sides custom, to use as part of my business cards. I'm going to be doing .900's, mainly again because of change machine compatibility. Not many change machines that I see have the hoppers for coins larger than quarters.
For 5,000 of them it's going to run $600 for the tokens, plus $400 for the die charges for custom on both sides.
-Hans "
If so and someone was making them for a community like this I think the best way to make the project happen would be to start off looking for a minimum of investors/preorders
for example
10 people paying $100 and getting 500 tokens each
or
20 at $50 = 250 tokens each
40 at 25 = 125 tokens
I think this would be an easier way to raise the cash to get things done. Personally I don't run my games off tokens but I'd still invest because it would be cool to have custom tokens. Personally I'd be in at either the $50 or $25 mark. Of course we would have to agree on design.