Bill, would it help if I took pics of me measuring my cabinet? All 3 of my measurements differed slightly from yours. But for instance we're only talking about 1/32" on the overall width (21/32 vs 20/32). Maybe you don't care about 1/32" but I figured it's better to be right on the money as opposed to having a sliver of the board's edge exposed.
My cab is particle board for the record.
And as for the 1/2" thing, I guess you're referring to pcolson's comment? I got the sense he was only talking about cp's in that post not the whole cab. So I'm guessing he has a home made cp and you shouldn't worry about it.
So even though you seem to be getting overwhelmed by the data you're getting, it seems to me the only "real" issue here is dialing in the measurements to a higher level of precision. I'd still buy if you decide to just stick with 5/8", but it just won't turn out quite as good as if you perfect the measurements.
Then again, it's conceivable that my calipers are wrong. I could try confirming my measurements with a regular tape measure too.
My cab is particle board for the record.
And as for the 1/2" thing, I guess you're referring to pcolson's comment? I got the sense he was only talking about cp's in that post not the whole cab. So I'm guessing he has a home made cp and you shouldn't worry about it.
So even though you seem to be getting overwhelmed by the data you're getting, it seems to me the only "real" issue here is dialing in the measurements to a higher level of precision. I'd still buy if you decide to just stick with 5/8", but it just won't turn out quite as good as if you perfect the measurements.
Then again, it's conceivable that my calipers are wrong. I could try confirming my measurements with a regular tape measure too.

