Woot, got it. The support piece that the bezel actually fits into is sitting just a tiny bit low, so it was getting caught on the back edge.

I'm gonna prop it up with something tomorrow but for the meanwhile I got it out.
None of the buttons on the CP were working....was examining the connectors on the CP...they were all connected so was like...what the hell's going on?
One of the pins on the connector broke clean off the back of the edge connector! <BLEEP!>
Didn't have any wire to do a jumper and I wasn't about to unhook this whole harness to fix one stupid broken pin! Got my soldering iron, dropped me a big ol' noobie blob of solder on top of the end of the wire, stuck it down on the sliver of exposed metal, and melted the bitch in there. Yes, I know it's wrong.
Yes, it's *working*. Oh look, all buttons on the CP work now....lol. Guess at some point I should learn how to fix this the right way, because looking at it, I could see how more of these could easily break off....