While I'm not sure if I'd pick LW3 over JD, I'm not really crazy about JD at all. The humor didn't really come off very well to me, the music is kind of sucky, and the modes are honestly a little strange. The software package is kind 'awkward', being this weird mix of seriousness and humor, that to me just makes it sort of strange while you're playing it. The playfield itself has a lot of good shots, and it's a lot of fun from that aspect. Plus it has this worthless supergame with it as well...if they would have combined those modes into the regular game it would have made the game a lot better. Probably rambling here, basically if you like JD or dark humor, you'll love the game, if you don't then the game will be average to below average to you.