It appears that 2nd(likely), 3rd and 4th place save.... but 1st place does not? WTF? I reset high scores... I get 3rd and 4th... then 1st. Upon reset 3rd and 4th are there, but my 1st place score reset??
OK... I had 3rd and 4th... I just played again 2 player and got 1st and 2nd dropping 3rd and 4th to 5th and 6th... upon power cycle my freakin 3rd and 4th place were back and my 1st and 2nd were gone?!?
It appears I figured it out. I had the game set on 3/7 man mode (3 man for a single quarter 7 men for 2). Scores were only being saved for the 3 man games not the 7 man. On a hunch I switched it to 5 man and it saved the highest score.... I guess I got 3rd and 4th with 3 men games.