EDIT: DO NOT BUY THESE!!! They do NOT fit into Atari 2600 joystick ports and I have ruined my all-original beautiful 2600's port trying to do so. I repeat! DO NOT buy these!
You might want to include a link to the specific joystick you are talking about if you don't have the Make & Model or post a picture of the joystick (either a stock photo or your own...or both). Also, maybe make a video comparing the "clickiness." I've heard that word a lot from you and I'm still not sure what to reference for how loud it is.
EDIT: DO NOT BUY THESE!!! They do NOT fit into Atari 2600 joystick ports and I have ruined my all-original beautiful 2600's port trying to do so. I repeat! DO NOT buy these!